How can a strong woman signal her submissiveness?

After several drinks with some theatre friends the other night, the conversation turned to dominance and submission within a relationship. Always fun. :-) (Now, I've never told any of those friends explicitly that I am seeking a Taken In Hand style relationship.) One guy went round the table, trying to pick whether each person was predominantly dominant or submissive in the bedroom. Pretty soon this became a bit of a game and everyone did it.

I was shocked and surprised that out of ten people in the room, every single one of them picked me to be dominant! (Except for an ex of mine, who cracked up laughing.) Now, I know within myself that I'm not. The few friends and ex-boyfriends I've told know that I'm not. But the fact that a whole room of people that know me quite well thought that I was, got me to thinking – if this is the image of me that my friends have, what on earth are the men I'm meeting thinking of me?!

I do not fit the mould of a submissive woman. This I know. I keep my hair short because it's easy and it suits me. I wear funky, comfortable clothes (except when I go out, when it's funky and a bit sexier). My makeup is either non-existent or super-dramatic depending on my mood. I'm tall and broad-shouldered. I am extremely vivacious and social and have never had a problem talking to people about anything (and I'm a huge flirt!). And whilst I love getting dolled up and wearing stockings, skirts and heels, I'm also the first one to don jeans and pick up power tools when the need arises. I am feminine – both by definition (that I'm female) and by connotation, and I'm very happy with the fact that I'm a woman. I'm not trying to be one of the guys.

Please don't get me wrong – I can be girly (how I hate that term) but usually only when I'm playing. I have no respect for the women I meet who are really girly-girls because more often than not, they seem to be air-headed and useless and their presence completely counter-productive when you're trying to get something done. I just don't have it in me to giggle and bat my eyelids and have deep and meaningful conversations about manicures. I've never even had a manicure because it makes playing the guitar impossible!

Now, here's the crunch. I love the way I am. I'm proud of my body, my personality and my opinions. I love that I am strong and independent and can walk home alone at night (gasp!). I wouldn't want any of that to change. What I do want is a man who is stronger. But, god help me, I just can't seem to find them! Where are they? And how can I attract the type of guy I want without diluting myself?

Eric wrote a fascinating article which gave me a little hope, but now I just don't know. All of the articles that I have read (and I thank each and every author for sharing their experiences) deals with Taken In Hand either within an existing relationship or in theory. I want to open the floor here and ask you all for some advice. How do I convey my submissiveness to a potential partner, when everybody seems to think the opposite? Keep in mind that I don't necessarily want to broadcast exactly what I do in the bedroom to guys I hardly know! And (specifically for the guys) would you date a gal you perceived to be more dominant, for the challenge in making her submit?

Bel

Take the Taken In Hand Tour


Have you seen the following articles?
What easy-to-say word gives every lover pleasure?
Changing for myself
Asserting dominance physically forcefully
Submission in fits and starts
Wanting a masterful man
Actions speak louder than words
Where are all the strong men?
Subjugation or submission?
Each to his own
What Taken In Hand is, and what it is not

Strong women CAN be submissive, we know it

Bel, your piece is beautifully expressive of a really key issue in the realm of male/female relations. I can understand completely the position you are in, because I am in it too. I am tall, broad-shouldered, and strong, and outweigh the average "girly" by 50 lbs. And I am capable and independent in all the ways you are, and outspoken, have a career in a male-dominated business, and am proud to be able to "kill my own snakes" (which, by the way, Mrs. Andelin in Fascinating Womanhood says a lady should never do). No one would ever guess that I wanted to be submissive in an intimate relationship.

And I think that is the key -- people shouldn't be guessing. If someone does not know you well, there is no reason for them to even be guessing; and if you are close, or are becoming, close to them, then it is up to you to tell them (him). Ironically, you must be assertive enough to express your need to submit, and ask for that need to be met.

And this is easier said than done, I know. I am in a relationship of 5 years and am only now figuring out that I want to be Taken in Hand, and to (gently) ask my lover to do this. He is listening, but I need to figure out how to ask even more directly. I am looking forward to the sweet reward of doing so.

May you find your own sweet reward in the man who knows how to admire your many strengths and also to assert his own over you.

Cicely

Guessing

Thank you Cicely for your lovely comments. It's great to have a kindred spirit!

You said that "that is the key - people shouldn't be guessing" and whilst I agree with you on an idealistic level, with all due respect I can't help but think that it's still not getting me very far!

Maybe Aussie men are a bit different to most.... :) I don't know - but I seem to attract the more submissive guys, when I don't want to. The quiet, sweet, lovely "new men". They make great friends, they're just not what I want in a partner. I don't think that it's a case of them guessing anything consciously - just something that I am "putting out there" that attracts the kind of guys I'm not attracted to to at all. If it were a tap, I'd turn it the hell off!

I guess what I'm asking is, what is it that I can do (if anything!), without changing myself overmuch, that will put across the right "vibes" (for lack of a better term).

Thanks again

Bel

How to signal

If the kind of conversation you had with your ten friends occurs again (with them or with another group), you might want to make a joking comment like "you know, I wish I could find a man more dominant than I am but most of the guys I know are just wimps."

That kind of comment would be perceived as a challenge to the male ego. Some of the men present might rise to the bait and others will sit quiet.

They guy you are looking for is the one who takes you seriously and is supportive. He may say something like "keep looking, you'll find some" or "Oh, I bet you know some strong men and don't know it".

The guy you don't want is the one who takes the bait ("Oh yeah, I got your dominance right here") or shows off or complains ("Hey, I'm not a wimp!").

The guy you *really* don't want is the one who puts you down or tries to embarass you.

Strong guys have strong egos and can take it.

Another method: try putting the moves on a guy using a nice direct approach. Come on strong, displaying your dominant side in all its glory.

If he backs away or is afraid or "wimps out", he's not the right guy. If he stands his ground and flirts back or takes charge of the situation, then you've found someone interesting.

Bottom line: if you think a man might be dominant, push him. If he is strong and likes to dominate strong women, you might just find the tables turned on you.

That self-protective mechanism

Both men and women need to understand that a young woman's assertiveness is both a natural and desirable self-protective mechanism. Generally men fail to appreciate this aspect of a woman's personality until they have daughters and discover certain young men, of whom they do not approve, attracted to them! This allows women to be selective in *her* choice of mates.

One common mistake that women make is in expecting men to take the lead in establishing a relationship. While true to the ideal, these days passively taking what comes along often results in women wishing to be taken in hand all too often dating aggressive - even predatory - wolves rather than assertive men. Smooth talkers do not always make for good husbands or even decent friends!

For more, see this article.

Finding the Dominants

Bel, there's a universal bdsm symbol that appears on The Castle and other D/s websites. You could get a ring or necklace with this symbol and wait. Sooner or later someone will recognize it. If a person doesn't recognize it but just asks, make up some other answer.

Wear a stylishly decorated leather choker. Sooner or later someone will remark that it looks like a slave collar. There's your opening.

Carry a copy of "Beauty's Awakening," "Story of O," or "Exit to Eden." Someone who read the book will open a conversation. This gives you a chance to feel him out and see if his interests match yours.

What if you're not BDSM?

To the poster that said to use the universal BDSM symbol --

Thanks but what if you're not into BDSM, you just want a naturally dominant man, like most single women on this site? I don't want "a Dominant", I want a man that will wear the pants in our relationship -- a man that will be the head of our household -- not some guy who thinks he knows it all and has me in a collar calling him "Sir" or "Master".

You go, girl!

Hiya Bel!

A gay friend of mine tells me he can walk into a room with 100 men and find the one homosexual among them within ten minutes. He has developed the ability to pick up the signals because he has to, because gays can`t usaully be overt the way heteroes are. Heterosexual men rarely need develop the ability to pick up this sort of signaling, so we don`t.

Consequentially, I think the easiest thing to do is to say what you have just put in writing. Don`t bother too much with discrete signals only gays and other women can read. Tell potential suitors that you are looking for a man who is stronger then yourself. Unless you live within a very strict PC regime this should be accepted as a slightly risque, tongue-in-cheek remark. People will go "hehe you are crazy to say such a thing" and you can chuckle along with them.

Someone will notice, sooner or later. And if he hasn`t got 100% of what it takes to handle you to begin with, he will develop that in time. All you need do is reward taken-in-hand type of behavior (really? how interesting, tell me more...) and punish the PC kind (oh right. they taught you this in school, huh?).

You go, girl! Though somehow it strikes me, you`ll be all right without my advice:)

Cheers
Scipio

Respect the man as he is

I disagree. Find the guy who is what you want him to be. Or talk to him about what you want and need if you see potential. Don't train him like one of Pavlov's puppies. What kind of respect is that?

Imposing oneself on one's surroundings

Bel is wrong to condition her surroundings to her presence if, and only if, behaviorism is a faulty prism through which to view human behavior. If this is so, we must use another prism: Freudian, psycho-dynamic, humanitarian or cognitive, etc. Personally I am inclined to stay where I stand. Bel must impose herself upon her surroundings and interact with them in such a way as to further her goals in life, as must we all. We instruct our surroundings, as our surroundings instruct us. The rest is all details. There is no way out.

Cheers
Scipio

Strong, Intelligent women are more interesting.

Hello Bel,

Personally I love strong, intelligent women. Women like you are so much more interesting, to me. What a great team two intelligent, strong people make! The conversation for one thing, and then you mentioned the bedroom. A strong, intelligent woman is more likely to speak up about her feelings and desires, in my opinion. Again, an involved partner is much more satisfying. I’m not clear on a couple things, though. What exactly is the role you want a man in your life to take? Are you looking for him to dominate you in the bedroom primarily, or are you looking for more of the traditional dominant man? I’m assuming your mean the latter.

I like what Carl said, “The guy you want will take you seriously and be supportive. He may say something like, Oh, I’ll bet you know some strong men and don’t know it”. I’ll bet that’s very true, Bel. You may need to look a little closer and consider the kind of person you could love and trust enough to submit to. There are lots of loud dominant guys out there, but they are just looking for a challenge and they won’t know what to do with you if they win you anyway. As the more intelligent partner, you’ll be cleaning up their messes for ever. On the other hand, the wusses are nice people, but they need you to mother them in some way. The guy who’s quietly confident is probably a better choice. You may have quiet down a bit yourself to seek him out, though. He won’t be trying to get your attention Bel, because he doesn’t need you like the wuss or the loud mouth. He’s already had a mother and he doesn’t need another challenge to prove he’s man.

I’m not sure I answered your question, but I hope that helps.

Bill

A Little Further...

Hi everyone and thanks so much for your advice and supportive comments! I agree with Carl and Bill - the kind of man I'm looking for is the quietly confident one who is supportive, not the loudmouth jerk or the wuss. :)

Bill - to answer your question, I'm looking for a man who is dominant in general. One who doesn't mind a bit of kink in the bedroom (in fact, one who is prepared to initiate it would be nice!), but is masculine and strong and a leader in the relationship. It's not that I don't want to take responsibilty for my own life (I've been doing that perfectly well up till now!) but I want someone who will offer guidance, support and not be afraid to bring me down to earth when I go "off with the pixies" as I am wont to do!

With my search for a dominant guy in mind (and a bit of coaxing from a kinky friend of mine) I decided to begin my hunt this weekend just gone in possibly the stupidest of places. I went to a BDSM nightclub here in Sydney. Didn't find anyone, but I'm not sure if that was because I was a bit intimidated by the people in the room, or because I truly could not tell who was dominant and who was not! I had a great night, though, and danced until dawn (or 5am, anyway. Daylight savings and all that). It was my first "outing" in the kink community, and it was heaps of fun and everyone was so friendly. :) I decided though that the BDSM scene really isn't what I'm into (after watching a gorgeous sub get glad-wrapped to a pillar) and I don't think that I'll find my knight in shining armour there. My housemaid in shining latex, maybe, but not my knight!

So, it's back to my old haunts again, taking in the advice that you guys have given me (and hopefully will continue to give!). Scipio - thank you for the lovely comments, but your second post is a bit of a mystery to me! :) I did theatre at uni, unfortunately, when it's clear that a psyche major would have helped me in my plight. If you could explain your post further, I would be much obliged!

To everyone else, thank you. I have taken some excellent ideas from you all, and your words of encouragement are so wonderful and touching. :) Please don't go away! I promise to keep you all updated in my search for a dominant man... There's a guy at work that I'm a bit sweet on, and intend to ask out for a drink tomorrow, so we'll see where that leads us!

Cheers!
Bel

I come from a matriarchal family

I come from a matriarchal family - and I do not think that was what my mother wanted, but my father never stood up but to whine like a spoilt teen. Consequently, we three daughters have grown up with a backbone of steel, and a forked tongue.

I have found my centre with my husband - I'm glad that he managed to hold out for the ten years it took for me to work out my own life. He is gentle... and very strong. I guess God was sneaky and had me marry my match before I knew how to have relationships with ... well... anyone but me.

One of my sisters has a weaker boyfriend, and I can tell she has no respect for him, no matter how she loves him. He might be stronger but she isn't responding to that.

The other sister is bemoaning being over 30 and single. I have lent her Facinating Womanhood... and she is rather excited... there is hope!

Back on topic... I love my jeans and my 'trackies', I play a mean game of paintball, I know more about technology, gaming, and scifi then most men... but I'm no longer hiding that I'm a girl. I'm no longer annoyed and frustrated. I can wear my hair in soft curls, put on some makeup, highheels, and wear my jeans and t-shirt (isn't fashion fantastic at the moment?)... I can wear what my guy calls The June Cleaver 1940-50's inspired clothing and add some gothic accents. I can have a ball of fun because I am as good as the guys... but I don't have to BE a guy.

Hold on there Bel! Your dream man is out there and ready to love and cherish you!

Cheers,

Suzette

"But sun it is not, when you say it is not, And the moon changes even as your mind: What you will have it names, even that it is, And so it shall be still, for Katharine."

If you've got - it flaunt it!

I'm also a strong and submissive woman. I do not see the two qualitites as opposites, it just means you need a man a little bit more dominant than the rest. Nothing wrong about being above average, is there now?

So if you want to succeed in life, be sure to show your true colours and the man dominant enough will know. When you find a man you like, you should definitely show your backbone and assertiveness, he'll see it as a challenge and the flirting will begin. A little teasing glimmer in your eye never hurts of course.

Best of luck!

Portia

Explaining post

Bel

Second post just an elaboration on a minor point of the first.

Given that we are responsible for the consequences of our own actions, you will not be happy with your suitors until you provide them with sufficient information upon which to act. In other words, you must be clearer in your communication in order to attract/develop the man you seek. Attract, because he's there. Develop, because we all develop all the time, in reaction to the rewards and punishments we are given. Does the "alpha male" react to rewards and punishments the same way everyone else does? Probably, else he fails to mate and his genes die, making him redundant.

There is no choice but to: Reward the behavior you seek. Punish the behavior you dislike. The man of dreams is partly in your making, though not wholly. Being a submissive woman does not free you from being proactive in your interactions with your surroundings. There is nothing else then punishment (any action decreasing the probability that the specific behavior will occur) and reward (any action increasing the probalility that the specific behavior will occur). Unless you are picky, in which case there is reinforcement (removing a reward/punishent). You must communicate ( I am looking for a man stronger then me), reward (oh, that`s interesting) and punish (yeah, well...).

You will succeed. Tell us more about crazy Syd!
Cheers Scipio

Bel's dilemma

Im kind of in a similar situation as yours... although I am small and girly looking, I have always been the tomboy type and been in male-dominated careers. Outwardly I am a go-getter and very assertive. Over the years I have been jokingly accused of being a dominatrix, though I am capable of it, I am actually a submissive.

To make a long story short, I would strongly urge you to use the internet as your main tool. You can explain and discuss your situation before meeting anyone in person.

I met 5 or 6 men online-then in person before I met my mentor who has been disciplining me for a year now. They all told me the same thing...that if they had known me from a public setting such as work, or a social function of some kind, that they would have never guessed I was a submissive and would not have approached me.

And the few people who know my secret were extremely shocked to find out.. 2 ex's and a male co-worker.

I have found that 'signals' don't work, I flat out tell a prospective man exactly what I need and am looking for, from the safety of the computer of course! Which also allows me to weed out the weirdo's and the players, and there have been many!!! If it weren't for the internet, it would have never happened.

What do you mean by the term

What do you mean by the term "mentor"? Do you mean boyfriend or significant other? Is this a loving sexual relationship or that of a friend who is helping you in areas of your life by using physical discipline?

mentor

A mentor is someone you look up to and learn from , but usually not a parent. Could be a coach, a teacher, neighbor etc. No we are not having any sex. He is an older "friend" who holds me accountable for staying on the right track and improving myself. He has saved me a lot of money in therapy and stress-related bad habits. He is a wonderful counselor and his guidance, support, and firm hands have saved me from God only knows what.

My life has improved enormously this last year and I long for the day I find a husband with his qualities. I feel priveleged and hope that Bel and anyone else seeking this kind of relationship find what they are looking for.

spotting dominant/submissive individuals

I did find this interesting. I can remember being asked a similar sort of question at a dinner party, I think people had to guess who was the dominant one in each of the couples' relationships. Everyone apparently thought I was not dominant, and would be bossed around by my girlfriend. We both found this hilarious, bearing in mind she used to like it if I led her around on a leash! Not that the rest of the table needed to know that, but I still thought it was quite amusing how badly people can be misjudged.

In fact I don't know why people find this strange, it's almost a cliche that the people with a lot of power in their lives (e.g. judges) like being submissive. I on the other hand am not exactly submissive in my normal life- I'll always stand up for what I believe in, for example- but I don't particularly enjoy ordering people what to do.

Because it's almost impossible to tell what people find a turn-on just by looking at them, personally I found the simplest thing was to go for women I found attractive, and then use things like forceful kissing or holding them down in bed to find out whether they enjoyed it. If they didn't, then the relationship tended to be over quite quickly.

I personally think this is easier for dominant men to find out than submissive women, because it's difficult to 'force' someone to be dominant over you, especially if you like to struggle a little. They might think you really don't like it.

So don't try and give signs! Men aren't very good with signs anyway. If you find them attractive and think they might have the potential to be dominant, just tell them that you'd like that. When I was somewhat more inexperienced, and wasn't trying anything much myself, the girlfriend I'd been with a few weeks (the same one I was at that dinner party with later) just told me that she liked to have her hair pulled. After being told that, it was fairly clear what was going on, and actually I couldn't believe my luck, as I had always been secretly dominant, but had found it difficult to deal with, and difficult to find a partner. So, tell your partner! He might secretly want to be dominant, but not realise that's what you want. If you tell him and he's not into it... well, I guess you would then have to decide how important it is to you. Personally I haven't tended to stay with women who weren't submissive, whereas I've had very deep relationships with women where we were sexually compatible. But other people love their partners for other qualities, and perhaps get their dominance/ submission needs taken care of in another way.

I understand completly

I agree that it is hard to find a dominant male when you are a woman with a dominant, outgoing personality. I am very much the same. As a single mother, I had to be in complete control. Generally when I saw a man who interested me for one reason or another, I didn't approach him except to talk as a friend. (I tended to be rather meek when interested)

Sometimes you can feel the stifled strength raging quietly beneath a meek mask and help your man to re-train himself to be who he always was but was unallowed to be by domineering women. (I have always been adept at helping people to mutate into a fuller and complete version of themselfes and who they wanted to be.)

Sometimes patience, perserverance, and a bit of dominant-type action is all that's needed. I wish you the best of luck. Let me tell you a short story.

I found my mate (lifemate, male counterpart, husband, whatever, pick a word) at a dinner of friends. We chatted for a while and I made it known to him that he would be mine. I know it is a bit backwards from the way you would think one would do things, but he had been trained for years by other women to be a wimp despite his natural tendencies towards dominance. (many have) He decided at the same time that I would be his. We chatted for about a month via IM and dates, all the while with me encouraging him to be the real man I saw inside of him. I am always yeilding and submissive in the bedroom, and he has always known that he is in complete control there, but we had come to a plateau in his realization of himself as a real man in other aspects of our lives. We have been together for a little over a year now, and tonight I finally told him that I wanted him to take me in hand, and what that meant to me. Tomorrow is the beginning of a new journey for us both.

It can and does happen. It took me years to find the right man and the right method, but being forward worked for me so that I could find a man who was capable of facing my strength without fear and could take me in hand. Don't give up hope!

You are so right Noon! Smoot

You are so right Noone! Smooth talkers rarely make good anythings! Leave them alone, they are usually incapable of being kind, loving and assertive! They are usually scared of being themselves (hence why they develop a smooth line) and out of fear often comes meaness!

Just tell him what you want, gradually

Bel,

I'm in a new relationship with a woman who, like you, is strong, commanding and feminine. And she also has no problem establishing boundaries and expressing expectations. But as we got to know each other, she revealed her need to be controlled by me little by little.

She gave me verbal hints and I took them.

It's a whole new experience for me, and I struggled with this at first. It is not my nature to lead, but I've worked on it and now we both enjoy our relationship and are having a wonderful time. It has been a growth experience for me.

So I say be brave and speak up. Tell your man what you want. It may take a while, but if all the other parts of the dynamic are good, then it may well grow into a richer and more satisfying relationship.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.